Call Now: (332) 296-8200 info@uncontesteddivorcelawyersnyc.com
Available 24/7 for Consultations
Free Consultation
← Back to Complete Guide to Uncontested Divorce in New York

No-Fault vs At-Fault: Why Choose Uncontested

Understanding whether to file for a no-fault or at-fault divorce is a critical step when preparing an uncontested divorce in New York. While most couples today choose the no-fault option—because it is simpler, faster, and less stressful—it’s helpful to know what each ground means, when they apply, and how they can affect your divorce paperwork, timelines, and settlement discussions. This guide explains the differences between no-fault and at-fault divorces, how each impacts uncontested filings, and why no-fault grounds are almost always the better choice for couples who agree on all terms.

What Is a No-Fault Divorce in New York?

A no-fault divorce means that neither spouse is blaming the other for the breakdown of the marriage. Instead, the filing spouse simply states that the marriage has experienced an irretrievable breakdown for at least six months. No specific misconduct needs to be proven.

Key Features of No-Fault Divorce

  • Easiest and fastest option for uncontested divorce filings

  • No need to prove wrongdoing or provide evidence

  • Both spouses agree the marriage cannot continue

  • Reduces conflict and unnecessary court involvement

  • Accepted by nearly all NY courts without issue

Because no-fault grounds require no explanation beyond the irretrievable breakdown, judges review and approve these cases much more efficiently. This is the primary reason 99% of uncontested divorces in New York use the no-fault option.

What Is an At-Fault Divorce?

An at-fault divorce is based on specific wrongful actions committed by one spouse. New York recognizes several fault grounds, but they are rarely used in uncontested cases because they require proof, supporting documents, and sometimes testimony.

Recognized At-Fault Grounds in New York

  1. Cruel and inhuman treatment

  2. Abandonment for one or more years

  3. Imprisonment for three years or more after marriage

  4. Adultery

  5. Conversion divorce (based on separation agreements or judgments)

Why At-Fault Grounds Are More Complicated

Filing an at-fault divorce adds additional challenges:

  • You must prove the fault with acceptable evidence

  • The other spouse may contest the allegations

  • More documents, witnesses, or affidavits may be required

  • Proceedings may take significantly longer

  • Judges scrutinize fault-based filings more closely

For couples seeking a quick, affordable uncontested divorce, these complications usually make at-fault grounds impractical.

Why No-Fault Divorce Is Best for Uncontested Cases

An uncontested divorce means both spouses fully agree on all issues—including property division, spousal support, and parenting arrangements. Because the couple is already cooperating, adding a fault ground only creates unnecessary conflict.

Benefits of Using No-Fault in Uncontested Divorce

  • Greater privacy — no public accusations

  • Easier paperwork — less documentation required

  • Faster processing — courts prioritize uncomplicated cases

  • Lower cost — no legal battle over proving fault

  • Reduced emotional stress for both spouses

Most importantly, the court cannot finalize a no-fault divorce unless all financial issues are already resolved, which naturally aligns with how uncontested cases work.

Does Fault Ever Matter in a New York Divorce?

Although most couples choose no-fault divorce, fault grounds may matter in limited situations—usually when spouses do not agree on key issues.

Fault May Influence:

  1. Negotiations – A spouse accused of serious misconduct may be more willing to settle.

  2. Spousal maintenance – Extreme wrongdoing can sometimes impact maintenance decisions.

  3. Safety or domestic violence concerns – At-fault filings may offer strategic legal protection.

However, even in these scenarios, attorneys often recommend filing no-fault and addressing the underlying issues through settlement negotiations instead of courtroom battles.

How Grounds Affect the Court Process

In a No-Fault Uncontested Divorce

  • Only the irretrievable breakdown statement is needed

  • No hearings or testimony are required

  • The court reviews and signs the judgment once paperwork is complete

  • The process is generally smooth and predictable

In an At-Fault Divorce

  • Evidence, affidavits, or witness statements may be needed

  • The accused spouse has the right to contest

  • Court appearances may be scheduled

  • The case can shift from uncontested to contested quickly

This is why even couples who experienced serious misconduct usually choose the no-fault option to avoid delays.

Choosing the Right Grounds: Practical Scenarios

**Scenario 1: Both spouses agree on everything

(Use No-Fault)**
The couple agrees on property, debts, parenting, and support. No-fault is the best choice because it results in the fastest and simplest divorce.

**Scenario 2: There was wrongdoing, but spouses still want to settle

(Use No-Fault)**
Even with adultery or abandonment, couples typically choose no-fault to avoid proving misconduct.

**Scenario 3: One spouse refuses to cooperate

(Consider At-Fault)**
If one spouse disappears, refuses communication, or blocks progress, fault grounds may allow the other spouse to move forward.

**Scenario 4: Safety concerns or abuse

(At-Fault may be useful in conjunction with legal protections)**
Fault filings, orders of protection, or emergency motions may be appropriate.

Required Documentation for No-Fault Grounds

Filing no-fault is straightforward. You only need:

  • A statement confirming a six-month irretrievable breakdown

  • Completed uncontested divorce forms

  • Property division agreement

  • Any required child support or custody documents

No screenshots, photos, messages, or witnesses are needed—which is not the case for at-fault filings.

Common Mistakes When Selecting Divorce Grounds

Even though no-fault divorces are simpler, errors sometimes cause delays. Avoid:

  • Mixing fault and no-fault grounds unnecessarily

  • Providing excessive or irrelevant details in affidavits

  • Filing fault grounds without proper evidence

  • Using outdated forms or incorrect language

  • Believing fault grounds increase settlement amounts (they rarely do)

A clean, well-prepared no-fault filing is the fastest route to a finalized uncontested divorce.

Why Professional Help Makes the Process Easier

Whether you choose no-fault or at-fault grounds, working with an experienced NY uncontested divorce professional ensures:

  • Correct choice of grounds

  • Proper preparation of all documents

  • Clear explanation of rights and responsibilities

  • Faster court approval

  • Reduced chances of rejection or corrections

Our team handles everything—from selecting the right grounds to finalizing your divorce judgment—so you can move forward with confidence and peace of mind.

The Impact of Choosing No-Fault Grounds

No-fault filings keep personal allegations out of the public record and allow judges to focus on the agreement rather than disputed conduct.

When Fault Grounds Still Matter

If a spouse needs to prove abandonment or cruel treatment for strategic reasons, the matter becomes contested. Couples pursuing uncontested divorces almost always rely on no-fault.

Financial and Emotional Benefits of Collaboration

Cooperation reduces attorney fees, limits time away from work, and keeps parents on the same team for future co-parenting.

Converting a Heated Case to Uncontested

Mediation, collaborative law, or scheduled settlement conferences can transform a contentious matter into an uncontested resolution once agreements are signed.